There Is No New Media Community

Once upon a time in 2004 there was a new media community- back then we called them Podcasters. They were passionate, excitable, and ready to jump on any new opportunity they could create for themselves. Podcasters flew from all over the world to hang out at conventions they organized. For three years, New Media brought people together. Friendships were forged, business ventures launched, and through it all some amazing creations made their way onto the internet. The New Media community felt like a family.

Now it’s gone; the community has dissipated. And that’s okay.

Seriously, it’s okay. It took me a while to realize it, but disappearance of community is just the next major step towards permanence. Sure, it was sad to see some exciting projects lose steam or dissolve entirely, but it’s just the way of things. From the toils of early adopters and pioneers come both fruit and chaff. Once the spring season for New Media ended, it was time to tend the plants. That’s when I began to lament the disappearance of the New Media Community.

Community Exists on the Frontier

The cycle is not without precedent. Bloggers were considered a small group of enthusiasts before CNN paid them for full-time positions. I vaguely remember when there was an “Internet Community”, do you? Back in the days of Archie and UUEncode and Telnet? The Internet Community emerged as a natural product of the Computer Community. This was before my time, really, but I know the stories told by elders around the New Media campfires. Intensely interested pockets of engineers and tinkerers gathered in garages to make boxes that would process spreadsheets or calculate Ham Radio satellite orbits. They held meetings, traded secrets, drank a shitload of coffee.

Was the excitement all about the circuit boards, packets, and wires? No. These communities are not formed because of technology. Technology is just the fertile ground these pioneers settle upon. They- we -gathered and bonded because of our shared love for uncharted territory. Communities like these form because there is the promise of something no one has ever done before. Places nobody has seen. This is what binds us together as a community, and those bonds do not last forever.

Lighting the Torch

With every community formed on the cutting edge, there is always the inevitable dissolution. The band of brothers and sisters on the frontier, connected by their intense engagement, light a torch for the rest of the world to flock to. Sometimes, as with Computers and New Media, they do. The world embraces this new frontier. A small settlement like New Amsterdam grows to a city of over 9 million. Every home houses several computers, none of which were built by hand in a garage. Podcasts and blogs are as ubiquitous and unremarkable as radio and newspapers.

And that’s okay.

The community dissolves, diluted by mass adoption. And that’s okay. Some friendships remain strong, some businesses and ventures hold together, but the attitude towards New Media has changed. Territory has been well-charted, leaving only a few nooks and crannies left to explore. With mass exposure, the focus shifts from how it’s done to what is being done with it. The original community reacts as each individual is inclined.

Some run in ever-growing circles trying to lasso the community back together, wishing the heyday wouldn’t end. Some, like me, mourn the decline of the community. I know that mass adoption is what the community worked so hard to achieve, but sometimes it’s sad to see something mature. You adopt the kitten, but it grows into a cat. The sadness, in my case, comes from the uncertainty of where the next community will form. This frontier is paved and developed, where will the next New World be?

Finding the Next Community

Community is like a drug. I need my fix.

I’d like to be a part of a New Community. Some faces from the old community will meet me there, some will be responsible for inviting me there I’m sure. Old friends never vanish into the masses, but nothing can top the experience of being a part of something new. I want to lead, to innovate, to explore. I want to form new communities that make the old seem superficial. It’s not about the size of the community- quite the contrary, the size it what breaks it apart. The longing is for the intensity.

What communities are you a part of? Where are they going? Maybe I’m leading somewhere undiscovered and I just don’t know it yet. Maybe others will follow and we’ll start a new settlement on this frontier. We’ll form a community that lives intensely, then grows and scatters. Just like the New Media Community.

And that’s okay.

P.S.: If you liked what you read, please share it with others!

  • http://twitter.com/RebelsHeart Tango

    I like the article, however the burnt papyrus background it is on makes it difficult to read in places.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Believe me, I know. I want to redesign the site, but the person I’ve asked to do the redesign is swamped atm. In the mean time, you could subscribe via RSS at:

    http://feeds2.feedburner.com/MatthewEbelBlog

  • http://twitter.com/kauaiday Dayna Marcum

    @matthewebel How very right you are, these days. Moments ago I began the journey to build a new site. New Media is not about media at all, it is about the adventure of finding your brand…. on the road. Media, new media is not technology or production, it is people. People adventure. Your tour is going to ROCK because you have a healthy LOYAL audience and the new media tools ready, to take it places it would never go with you in a single studio. I have some things brewing. You need a few believers in wireless technology, your brand, and your mission, and Kaua’i needs you in the local scene for about a week or ten days. If there are 10 audience members that want to build their own businesses with you as their spokesperson, it would be fun to create something totally rad…. on island – ten days with Matthew Ebel…. just a thought…. talk about brand building – a ten for 1. technology included.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    God knows I’d love to come back to the islands. It’s always a matter of money, though… I just can’t afford the plane ticket and hotel yet!

  • Jersey Todd

    What an incredible eulogy. I just disagree about one thing – some friendships do, and will, continue.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Hmm, I thought I’d made that point with “Some friendships remain strong, some businesses and ventures hold together, but the attitude towards New Media has changed.” I probably could have made the point a little more effectively, though. Thanks!

  • http://twitter.com/RebelsHeart Tango

    I like the article, however the burnt papyrus background it is on makes it difficult to read in places.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Believe me, I know. I want to redesign the site, but the person I've asked to do the redesign is swamped atm. In the mean time, you could subscribe via RSS at:

    http://feeds2.feedburner.com/MatthewEbelBlog

  • http://twitter.com/kauaiday Dayna Marcum

    @matthewebel How very right you are, these days. Moments ago I began the journey to build a new site. New Media is not about media at all, it is about the adventure of finding your brand…. on the road. Media, new media is not technology or production, it is people. People adventure. Your tour is going to ROCK because you have a healthy LOYAL audience and the new media tools ready, to take it places it would never go with you in a single studio. I have some things brewing. You need a few believers in wireless technology, your brand, and your mission, and Kaua'i needs you in the local scene for about a week or ten days. If there are 10 audience members that want to build their own businesses with you as their spokesperson, it would be fun to create something totally rad…. on island – ten days with Matthew Ebel…. just a thought…. talk about brand building – a ten for 1. technology included.

  • http://EdRoberts.TV EdRoberts

    It took me a while to quantify and truly embrace how our band of pioneers went from such a family to were we are now. I even see the second generation of this community seeing another dissolution. Original pioneers starting their own pioneering communities and watching their new intimate communities dissolve with mass adoption. Such is the way of the pioneer. It’s a path destined and intended for that time when you step back in both awe and in saddness. Bittersweet, but good in the end.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    God knows I'd love to come back to the islands. It's always a matter of money, though… I just can't afford the plane ticket and hotel yet!

  • Jersey Todd

    What an incredible eulogy. I just disagree about one thing – some friendships do, and will, continue.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Hmm, I thought I'd made that point with “Some friendships remain strong, some businesses and ventures hold together, but the attitude towards New Media has changed.” I probably could have made the point a little more effectively, though. Thanks!

  • Suzietk

    I am glad to have been a part of that podcast community. It taught me a lot and the friends I gained was overwhelming!!

    Suzietk

  • Derek K. Miller

    Back at Northern Voice 2005, I made a point that something like a “blogging conference” was a temporary thing, because as technologies become more widespread and integrated into society, groups focused on the technology as it’s new fade away. Do we have “telephone user conferences”? “Car commuter conferences?” Meetings on how to watch television? No. Blogging and podcasting have become similar as they’ve become part of the mainstream. It’s true that the early community feel disappears in that process, but as you said, it is natural, and okay.

  • http://EdRoberts.TV EdRoberts

    It took me a while to quantify and truly embrace how our band of pioneers went from such a family to were we are now. I even see the second generation of this community seeing another dissolution. Original pioneers starting their own pioneering communities and watching their new intimate communities dissolve with mass adoption. Such is the way of the pioneer. It's a path destined and intended for that time when you step back in both awe and in saddness. Bittersweet, but good in the end.

  • Suzietk

    I am glad to have been a part of that podcast community. It taught me a lot and the friends I gained was overwhelming!!

    Suzietk

  • Derek K. Miller

    Back at Northern Voice 2005, I made a point that something like a “blogging conference” was a temporary thing, because as technologies become more widespread and integrated into society, groups focused on the technology as it's new fade away. Do we have “telephone user conferences”? “Car commuter conferences?” Meetings on how to watch television? No. Blogging and podcasting have become similar as they've become part of the mainstream. It's true that the early community feel disappears in that process, but as you said, it is natural, and okay.

  • http://twitter.com/mattstevensloop matt stevens

    The thing is all scenes are like this – its just a new generation of people coming thru like when prog went to punk :)

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Or when self-produced albums turned became something that anyone with a Macintosh could do in a dining room.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Me too, believe me! A lot of the friends I made in that crowd are still good friends, but we all seem to be working on different projects now.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Yeah, it’s gotta be something like watching your kids go to college. All you can think is, “wasn’t I picking out onesies just last month?”

  • http://twitter.com/mattstevensloop matt stevens

    The thing is all scenes are like this – its just a new generation of people coming thru like when prog went to punk :)

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Or when self-produced albums turned became something that anyone with a Macintosh could do in a dining room.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Me too, believe me! A lot of the friends I made in that crowd are still good friends, but we all seem to be working on different projects now.

  • http://matthewebel.com Matthew Ebel

    Yeah, it's gotta be something like watching your kids go to college. All you can think is, “wasn't I picking out onesies just last month?”

  • http://www.successful-blog.com/1/sob-business-cafe-09-03-10/ SOB Business Cafe 09-03-10 | Liz Strauss at Successful Blog

    [...] There Is No New Media Community [...]

  • @patgermelman

    Kittens do grow into cats and we keep loving them anyway. Not as cute. Not as playful. But we learn to take the good (because it is so very good) with the bad (that doesn’t take too much effort to overlook.) OK, enough with the cats. I love your post. Fantastic!!

  • @patgermelman

    Kittens do grow into cats and we keep loving them anyway. Not as cute. Not as playful. But we learn to take the good (because it is so very good) with the bad (that doesn't take too much effort to overlook.) OK, enough with the cats. I love your post. Fantastic!!