Don’t Unplug Your Customers

Blog

It’s amazing how some businesses will sacrifice $10 to save $1.

Update: A local business owner finally clued me in that commercial power around here is about 75¢ per kWh. I’ve re-done the whole article to match the new math. Higher than I thought, still not worth pissing off your customers.

I eat ate lunch pretty much every weekend at Aldo’s restaurant for the same reason I eat breakfast at the bakery every morning- free internet and a power outlet. Last year it was the perfect routine… donuts, coffee, blogging, then on to the performance or off to bike around the island. Seven days a week the bakery got my money and every weekend the restaurant served me at least two meals.

This year, however, they’ve covered all the power outlets. No more running the laptop on their dime. For all the tourists that drift through and considering rising energy costs, it makes sense, right? Wrong.

Do The Math

Unlike Aldo’s Bakery and Restaurant, I actually did the math. Here is the breakdown:

  • Avg. retail electricity price in RI: 13.98¢ per kWh
    http://www.eia.doe.gov/cneaf/electricity/epa/fig7p4.html
  • Block Island price: 75¢ per kWh
    According to a local business owner.
  • MacBook maximum hourly power draw: .06 kWh
  • .06 kwh x 75¢ = 4.5¢ per hour
  • Average time I spend at Aldo’s: 27 hours per week
  • 4.5¢ x 27 = $1.21 per week

The Worst Case Scenario

If ten MacBooks were plugged into the bakery’s ten outlets, running at full power draw, from open to close 17 hours a day, they would cost the restaurant a mind-boggling… um… $7.65 per day.

If all ten MacBook users spent only an hour here (45¢ total energy cost) and bought only one small cup of coffee each, they would pay for the next 20 people to do the same. (I know what the markup is on coffee at the bakery.)

For all 10 weeks that I’m on this island, if all 10 of us fictional MacBook users were cranking away at full steam in here, that’s a grand total of $535 they’ve spent in two and a half months assuming maximum capacity all the time.

But I am only one MacBook user. I am only here on average 27 hours a week to do my business and eat a couple of meals. At most, I am costing them $1.21 per week.

What is Aldo’s losing for that $1.21?

By making their power unavailable to me, they’re losing two lunch meals every weekend- a burger here is about $15 when all is said and done, somehow I doubt the profit margin is less than $1.21. They give the locals a 10-15% discount on some items, so they’re still making a profit at $13.50.

For $1.21 they’re losing a beer or two with each of those burgers. That’s a $4.50 Widmer Hefeweizen, usually, and between two beers I doubt the markup is less than $1.21. This is on tap, too, not in a bottle.

For $1.21 they’re losing all the Google juice that comes from me Twittering and blogging about my field office (this is probably the last post you’ll see on my site with Aldo’s in it).

The End Result

What do I see as a customer? I see a place that wants me to come in, spend money, and leave ASAP. I understand that costs are rising, but there are better (and far more effective) ways to save money. This move was obviously made without the customers in mind. It’s the same kind of move my web host made when they crammed twice as many sites onto one server and outsourced all their tech support to Mars.

Turn off the lights in the ice cream freezer and bakery displays when nobody’s in the restaurant (or better yet, install a motion sensor). Put a low-flow toilet in the bathroom. Turn off the TV’s in the bar until someone sits down for a drink (they draw more power than my MacBook anyway). Hell, charge me a quarter per hour… that’s over 5 times the cost.

But don’t take any steps that will cost you a customer unless you’re going to save more than that customer is spending. Do the math, see what’s really worth it and what isn’t.

Update: Just found out that Aldo’s will charge you $7 an HOUR if you want to plug in. Methinks this may not be an actual cost-saving move but a way to gouge tourists and locals at the same time. With a 60w power supply, that’s over $!00 per kWh. Shameful.


Join the email list!  

6 Responses to “Don’t Unplug Your Customers”

  1. Zimmie Says:

    Did you actually ask them if this is why the outlets are covered? I ask because it’s possible the fire marshall came and ordered them to do it or that sort of thing. Down in Houston, there was a big datacenter that had an explosion in their power distribution room. They had plenty of backup generator capacity, but the fire marshall told them that they could not use that room to distribute it.

    I know this for two reasons. First, I’m big into data security, and that means maintaining services even when a site is totally down. Second, I’m involved with Furry Fiesta, and that data center was hosting our site. ;-)

    Anyway, just wanted to say that it’s *possible* that there’s nothing sinister going on. Could be just a poorly wired building or something.

  2. Matthew Ebel Says:

    Zimmie-

    Oh yes, they have specifically mentioned that it’s because they were spending a ton of money on electricity. There was a man sitting next to me as I was typing this who paid them $7 to get them to uncover an outlet and let him plug in.

    That man could’ve funded my laptop use for the next 15 weeks.

  3. Zimmie Says:

    Alright. Figured as much, but like I said, I’m the kind of guy who likes to be absolutely sure.

  4. Frostbite Says:

    Did you tell the proprietors why you would not be coming back?

  5. Matthew Ebel Says:

    Frosty-

    Not yet, I was waiting until I saw actual Block Island power figures. Now that I know it’s still less than a dollar a week for heavy use, I’m going to find a new place to eat breakfast and write Aldo’s a letter. They won’t care.

  6. Christopher S. Penn Says:

    The irony is that according to the DOE, Block Island is *ideally* suited for virtually every form of alternative energy there is. It gets great wind for windmills, constant sun, and waves for wave-motion generation.

    If any restaurant on Block Island were to deploy even a few solar panels or a small marine windmill, they could not only recoup the cost, not only offer free power to their customers, but also sell energy back to BIPCO at a hefty premium.

    http://tinyurl.com/netmeter

    Rhode Island is one of 29 states that has mandated net-metering under 25 MW. Thus, any utility is required to buy back power generated privately under 25 MW.

    A Sunforce 44444 is $600 and can generate 400W, or 9.6 kWh per day. It would take just shy of 6 months (assuming good winds all day) to pay for itself in power saved, and everything after that is gravy you can bill back to BIPCO. Even if the payback window is a year, most small wind turbines are rated for 10 years. Who wouldn’t want a pure profit center for 9 years, plus bragging rights that you’re the ONLY green shop on the island? Added bonus - the unit is 46 inches wide. That’s it. No mega-tower.

    Hey, who knows, you stay on that island long enough and maybe we’ll see Osprey Power & Light.

Leave a Reply

Want to see your picture next to your comments? Upload your avatar at Gravatar.com